Welcome to the Official Redemption® Message Board!
Is there a reason you're playing Black/Grey and don't have Antiochus?
Since you don't use any capture yourself, I would swap I am Redemption for Blue Tassels. That's just a style preference tho, (reactive vs proactive), both can be effective.
I Am Redemption doesn't help you at all during battle. It isn't nearly the same. I would also recommend Blue Tassels.
You may have been thinking of Cov-o-Palestine, which is not as good because it's a prevent.
I LOVE this deck, I just think the defense needs to be beefed up. Maybe lighten up the heroes/good enhs 1 or 2 a piece so you have 3-4 spots for more defense. Then you could take out House of Bethany, Hormah, Temple Veil, and Gifts of the Magi, all for more defense. That way you can just A-bomb your way to victory.