New Redemption Grab Bag now includes an assortment of 500 cards from five (5) different expansion sets. Available at Cactus website.
to play AoCP pre-block.
For starters, I'd drop ET, Reach, AoCP, Striking Herod, Scapegoat, and LuG. That gets you to 52, and you don't have handclog from mismatched battlewinners. Your Teal, plus your doms, is plenty of offense to get 5 redeemed souls.
I was thinking about taking out: OthoZimri Philosophy LuG Trembling Demon HoH Feast of Trumpets Scapegoat Striking Herod Cherubim and putting in: TAS KoT Gomer Haman's Plot Haggai That would make it 53. I could probably take out Benedictus since access won't be problem, but LSs hurt this deck.