New Redemption Grab Bag now includes an assortment of 500 cards from five (5) different expansion sets. Available at Cactus website.
In Redemption gameplay, "simultaneously" means "together," which is why a player can lay down SoG/NJ as a pair to rescue 2 Lost Souls but a player cannot lay down his NJ with another player's SoG.I will allow another Elder to confirm this and then we don't need to bother Rob.K?THXBYE
In Redemption gameplay, "simultaneously" means "together," which is why a player can lay down SoG/NJ as a pair to rescue 2 Lost Souls but a player cannot lay down his NJ with another player's SoG.I will allow another Elder to confirm this and then we don't need to bother Rob.
Quote from: The Guardian on November 17, 2010, 12:58:51 AMIn Redemption gameplay, "simultaneously" means "together," which is why a player can lay down SoG/NJ as a pair to rescue 2 Lost Souls but a player cannot lay down his NJ with another player's SoG.I will allow another Elder to confirm this and then we don't need to bother Rob.K?THXBYE Dude, you dont NEED another elder to make rulings... look at all of your titles!The Guardian~~Deck Architect~~Official PlaytesterTournament HostRedemption ElderRedemption ElderYeah, you're so cool, you're TWO redemption elders at the same time. That gives you the power to make a ruling official just with your opinion. Shazam!
I'm sorry Rob has never ruled it that way so it's not official
To help resolve ruling issues, the following people have authority to making rulings in the game. If at least two people on the list rule on an issue it can be read with a higher degree of confidence. Also, if one of these Elders post a ruling and states that the ruling was reached by consensus it can be understood to settle an issue.1) Mike Berkenpas, 2) Tim Maly, 3) Bryon Hake, 4) Stephen Schafer, 5) Justin Alstad, 6) Gabe Isbell, 7) Kevin Shride, 8 ) Eric Largent, 9) Chris Bany, 10) John Michaliszyn, 11) Rob Anderson, 12) Roy Cruz, 13) Mark Underwood, 14) Jordan Alstad
postcount.add(1);
Quote from: JSB23 on November 17, 2010, 01:35:42 AMI'm sorry Rob has never ruled it that way so it's not officialQuote from: CactusRob on May 25, 2010, 07:10:40 AMTo help resolve ruling issues, the following people have authority to making rulings in the game. If at least two people on the list rule on an issue it can be read with a higher degree of confidence. Also, if one of these Elders post a ruling and states that the ruling was reached by consensus it can be understood to settle an issue.1) Mike Berkenpas, 2) Tim Maly, 3) Bryon Hake, 4) Stephen Schafer, 5) Justin Alstad, 6) Gabe Isbell, 7) Kevin Shride, 8 ) Eric Largent, 9) Chris Bany, 10) John Michaliszyn, 11) Rob Anderson, 12) Roy Cruz, 13) Mark Underwood, 14) Jordan AlstadOkay? Okay cool.
Isn't New Jerusalem basically A New Beginning for God's creation? Maybe we should rule them consistently.
Quote from: The Guardian on November 17, 2010, 01:38:24 PM... Mark Underwood,...How many times have those people said I am Holy + Chamber works?
... Mark Underwood,...
... all agree that SoG/NJ works. Case dismissed.
Does the SoG + NJ combo work? becuase it is humanly impossible to play them and make sure they hit the table at the exact same time (Which is what simultaneous means) so it's condition (being played simultaneously) hasn't been fulfilled therefore it shouldn't work. I'm going to need a ruling from Rob on this one because he's never made an actual ruling on it so it could go either way.
Quote from: Prof Underwood on November 17, 2010, 05:35:13 PM... all agree that SoG/NJ works. Case dismissed.Ergo, SoG/ANB works, too.
Quote from: STAMP on November 17, 2010, 06:39:19 PMQuote from: Prof Underwood on November 17, 2010, 05:35:13 PM... all agree that SoG/NJ works. Case dismissed.Ergo, SoG/ANB works, too. I concur
In Redemption gameplay, "simultaneously" means "together," which is why a player can lay down SoG/NJ as a pair to rescue 2 Lost Souls but a player cannot lay down his NJ with another player's SoG.K?THXBYE
