Cactus Game Design Message Boards

My opponent makes a rescue attempt with Lydia, I block with Philistine Priests.  He plays Spirit as a Dove, searches for SOG to go with his NJ.  He plays SOG NJ.  I play Bringing Fear.  What happens?

nothing since you can't unplay a card. SaaD got sog and it's played. Doms can't be negated anyways...

but they can be instead'ed 

and it really doesn't matter since insteaded isn't a word in the English language which "most" of us speak or at least try to

nothing since you can't unplay a card. SaaD got sog and it's played. Doms can't be negated anyways...

This is a common misconception. You can't negate the ability to play a card, but you can send a card back where it came from and Negate it indirectly if it was searched for/drawn because of another card and then played.

In this case, SoG/NJ would still work because it's CBN, which stick to the table. However, if, say, I attack with the 1/1 Musician, you block with King Jehoakim and play 2KH, drawing Confusion and play it, I can use Cymbals of the Levites to Negate 2KH, indirectly Negating Confusion and sending it back to your deck. If you had drawn and played a CBN card instead, Negating Horses would not send it back nor negate it.

What happens when I negate a card that shuffles a card into my deck?

Quote from: SomeKittens on November 11, 2010, 09:45:10 AM

What happens when I negate a card that shuffles a card into my deck?

You fetch the card back out, and shuffle your deck again.

And what if that is negated?

Quote from: 3-Liner And Bags Of Chips on November 10, 2010, 09:48:50 PM

nothing since you can't unplay a card. SaaD got sog and it's played. Doms can't be negated anyways...

This is a common misconception. You can't negate the ability to play a card, but you can send a card back where it came from and Negate it indirectly if it was searched for/drawn because of another card and then played.

In this case, SoG/NJ would still work because it's CBN, which stick to the table. However, if, say, I attack with the 1/1 Musician, you block with King Jehoakim and play 2KH, drawing Confusion and play it, I can use Cymbals of the Levites to Negate 2KH, indirectly Negating Confusion and sending it back to your deck. If you had drawn and played a CBN card instead, Negating Horses would not send it back nor negate it.

I know that but this was with doms so that's why i said that...