Cactus Game Design Message Boards

I don't see how any of what I said contradicts those things. I attempted to write everything I could think of about the current subject so you could look through and point out the exact point you disagree on so we can figure it out.

I never said a place ability was a negate..I'm still not sure what your point is. In the case of Siegeworks the act of placing the card negates the target but I never said they were the same ability, just two separate abilities that happen consecutively like with Sam's Edict or a band ability.

If anything I said communicated that I think you're trying to mislead anyone I apologize, that has never been my intention. I'm not saying Gam's Speech can be played from hand, quite the contrary. I never thought it could be after Guardian's post, I just wasn't able to put a good explanation into words until I hashed it out some more. Also I never said a place ability was an interrupt or negate on its own. At this current point the only thing I am trying to say is that Siegeworks specifically can be played during SI because it meets negates the removal and there is no chance in between the card being played and the removal being negated in which the removal would have a chance to resolve.