Check out our Event Calendar! View birthdays, holidays and upcoming tournaments!
I know if a benefit is CBN that effectively makes the cost CBN as well
You cant negate an underdecking to my knowledge.
Quote from: DrowningFish on March 15, 2014, 04:48:23 PMYou cant negate an underdecking to my knowledge.That's not true. Lots of things can negate underdeck, just like any other ability. If something negated evil weapons, or evil enhancements, or there was just FBTN being used, then it would negate that part of it too.But yes, I thought it was the other weapon.Either way, the underdeck part can be negated even if the discard could not be. That would be my ruling.
but along with carcasses its a CBN vs CBN...
That would be negate versus CBN, not CBN versus CBN.
I would rule that the enhancement can be discarded but the effect would not activate.
My initial gut response is that the discard ability of Ish. Spear is CBN via Carcasses but that does not make the underdeck ability CBN.If Carcasses said "...evil enhancements with discard abilities cannot be negated" then it would make all of Spear CBN.