At Nats 2007 a guy at my T1-MP table rescued with Hur and shuffles his own hand -1 into his deck thinking he could Hur himself. Whomever the judge was rules that he had to keep playing with the 1 card he kept.
At a high level tournament I would probably rule it the same way. But during playgroup, or even at a low level tournament I would rule as ProfAlstad suggested.