If anyone knows of a better solution I'm open to suggestions.
Can there be a single board that only people appointed by the PtB can post to that has threads that look something like this.
Subject: Jerusalem Tower Ruled to Be a Protect
Body: The special ability on Jerusalem Tower has been ruled to be a protect ability.
This overrides the original ruling that the special ability on Jerusalem Tower was a negate.
For discussion see <hyperlink>this thread here.</hyperlink>
With the actual card name (not JT in this example) used in the subject and body to allow for easier searching, and no back and forth chatter. In an ideal world there would be one post for every single official ruling made that cannot be found anywhere other than on the boards. Something like this would allay my primary concern.
I understand that is what the official threads are supposed to serve and I will begin using it. The reasons I suggested something slightly different are threefold...
1) There appear to be at least three official threads--five if you count the two threads on the Errata board--that are all currently being used for this purpose.
2) Not every ruling is found there--only the "big" ones and those only since November
3) Searching a single thread is much more difficult to do than searching a board--unless you limit the posts to a single user who doesn't post elsewhere or somesuch
My other personal preference would be that existing rulings on cards would be given some considerable deference when revisiting a card. If there is no compelling reason to overturn a ruling, the ruling should not be overturned (even if the re-ruling may be slightly better if taken de novo). Rulings stability is a very good thing, and benefits the game greatly.
