Check out our Event Calendar! View birthdays, holidays and upcoming tournaments!
I think the rule was that you cannot tear a card in half that has already been torn in half. You would then be tearing it into fourths, which is not what the card says.
No - you have to play with one less card (or another deck you checked in) for the rest of the tournament.
No - if you tear HP and your deck is no longer legal, you can't use that deck anymore. This is in the tournament guide.
So you couldnt come prepared with extra hamans plot for a tournament. That doesn't seem fair, Escpecially if HP is part of your deck. you should be able to replace a card with the same card between rounds.
If you want to use many HPs, check 3 different decks each with one in it.
Quote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 04:46:42 PMSo you couldnt come prepared with extra hamans plot for a tournament. That doesn't seem fair, Escpecially if HP is part of your deck. you should be able to replace a card with the same card between rounds. I totally disagree; it is totally fair. Why should a player with a lot of cards be able to use a plot every single round? The idea of HP is that you choose the best strategic time to use it. HP isn't a card meant to be the base of a deck; it is an emergency card used when you need just one more block.If you want to use many HPs, check 3 different decks each with one in it.
Quote from: Cameron the Conqueror on August 10, 2009, 04:50:35 PMIf you want to use many HPs, check 3 different decks each with one in it.Just as a clarification...if the event will have five or less rounds, you can only check in two decks. If the event has six rounds or more you can check in 3 decks.Mike
No - you'd have to build 3 copies of the same deck.
Quote from: Cameron the Conqueror on August 10, 2009, 04:50:35 PMQuote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 04:46:42 PMSo you couldnt come prepared with extra hamans plot for a tournament. That doesn't seem fair, Escpecially if HP is part of your deck. you should be able to replace a card with the same card between rounds. I totally disagree; it is totally fair. Why should a player with a lot of cards be able to use a plot every single round? The idea of HP is that you choose the best strategic time to use it. HP isn't a card meant to be the base of a deck; it is an emergency card used when you need just one more block.If you want to use many HPs, check 3 different decks each with one in it.There are alot of decks built around alot of cards that you dont have to tear up. Michael and Michaels sword for example.In my opinion I think you should be able to replace a card like that in your deck if you are playing in a tourney.
Quote from: RedemptionAggie on August 10, 2009, 07:22:50 PMNo - you'd have to build 3 copies of the same deck.So I guess there are some legal options if you want to have HP in your deck every round at a tournament.
Quote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 07:15:02 PMQuote from: Cameron the Conqueror on August 10, 2009, 04:50:35 PMQuote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 04:46:42 PMSo you couldnt come prepared with extra hamans plot for a tournament. That doesn't seem fair, Escpecially if HP is part of your deck. you should be able to replace a card with the same card between rounds. I totally disagree; it is totally fair. Why should a player with a lot of cards be able to use a plot every single round? The idea of HP is that you choose the best strategic time to use it. HP isn't a card meant to be the base of a deck; it is an emergency card used when you need just one more block.If you want to use many HPs, check 3 different decks each with one in it.There are alot of decks built around alot of cards that you dont have to tear up. Michael and Michaels sword for example.In my opinion I think you should be able to replace a card like that in your deck if you are playing in a tourney.And why would you ever have to replace a Michael's Sword between rounds? And btw, very few recent decks use either of those.My point was there are alot of cards that decks are built around a card or set of cards. The fact is one there is a cards that gets ripped in half. So why am I not be able to replace the main part of my deck for the next round of the tournament. (I was using Micheal and his sword were and example).
Quote from: Cameron the Conqueror on August 10, 2009, 07:40:13 PMQuote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 07:15:02 PMQuote from: Cameron the Conqueror on August 10, 2009, 04:50:35 PMQuote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 04:46:42 PMSo you couldnt come prepared with extra hamans plot for a tournament. That doesn't seem fair, Escpecially if HP is part of your deck. you should be able to replace a card with the same card between rounds. I totally disagree; it is totally fair. Why should a player with a lot of cards be able to use a plot every single round? The idea of HP is that you choose the best strategic time to use it. HP isn't a card meant to be the base of a deck; it is an emergency card used when you need just one more block.If you want to use many HPs, check 3 different decks each with one in it.There are alot of decks built around alot of cards that you dont have to tear up. Michael and Michaels sword for example.In my opinion I think you should be able to replace a card like that in your deck if you are playing in a tourney.And why would you ever have to replace a Michael's Sword between rounds? And btw, very few recent decks use either of those. My point was there are alot of cards that decks are built around a card or set of cards. The fact is one there is a cards that gets ripped in half. So why am I not be able to replace the main part of my deck for the next round of the tournament. (I was using Micheal and his sword were and example).
Quote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 07:15:02 PMQuote from: Cameron the Conqueror on August 10, 2009, 04:50:35 PMQuote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 04:46:42 PMSo you couldnt come prepared with extra hamans plot for a tournament. That doesn't seem fair, Escpecially if HP is part of your deck. you should be able to replace a card with the same card between rounds. I totally disagree; it is totally fair. Why should a player with a lot of cards be able to use a plot every single round? The idea of HP is that you choose the best strategic time to use it. HP isn't a card meant to be the base of a deck; it is an emergency card used when you need just one more block.If you want to use many HPs, check 3 different decks each with one in it.There are alot of decks built around alot of cards that you dont have to tear up. Michael and Michaels sword for example.In my opinion I think you should be able to replace a card like that in your deck if you are playing in a tourney.And why would you ever have to replace a Michael's Sword between rounds? And btw, very few recent decks use either of those.
Quote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 09:46:07 PMQuote from: Cameron the Conqueror on August 10, 2009, 07:40:13 PMQuote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 07:15:02 PMQuote from: Cameron the Conqueror on August 10, 2009, 04:50:35 PMQuote from: Matman on August 10, 2009, 04:46:42 PMSo you couldnt come prepared with extra hamans plot for a tournament. That doesn't seem fair, Escpecially if HP is part of your deck. you should be able to replace a card with the same card between rounds. I totally disagree; it is totally fair. Why should a player with a lot of cards be able to use a plot every single round? The idea of HP is that you choose the best strategic time to use it. HP isn't a card meant to be the base of a deck; it is an emergency card used when you need just one more block.If you want to use many HPs, check 3 different decks each with one in it.There are alot of decks built around alot of cards that you dont have to tear up. Michael and Michaels sword for example.In my opinion I think you should be able to replace a card like that in your deck if you are playing in a tourney.And why would you ever have to replace a Michael's Sword between rounds? And btw, very few recent decks use either of those. My point was there are alot of cards that decks are built around a card or set of cards. The fact is one there is a cards that gets ripped in half. So why am I not be able to replace the main part of my deck for the next round of the tournament. (I was using Micheal and his sword were and example). My point is that HP is designed to NOT be a main part of a deck, on purpose. It is the only card that does this (and was only made OP'D because of the ripping) and thus should not be made as a deck foundation.Use it for backup and occasional use; not as a main deck strategy.
