Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Do Cloud heroes brought into battle with Faith of Samuel have to share the same book with the non-Cloud heroes in order to draw 3? 

Or does Faith of Samuel split the heroes into mutually exclusive groups, and the non-Cloud heroes are the ones that need to share a book?

I actually think the second view is correct, but I'd like to see what everyone else thinks.  If everyone else agrees with me, there's no need to argue for it 

Faith of Samuel - Interrupt the battle.  Hero may band to any number of human heroes.  If all of those heroes are Cloud heroes or share the same book, you may draw 3.

Ok, that makes sense.  I was reading the card wrong.  Thanks.

*****

EDIT:  So I'm curious...  If there was an EE printed that said:

"If all of your Evil Characters are Roman or Greek, discard a hero."

...You are saying the only way to discard a hero would be for either ALL of your ECs to be Roman, or ALL of your ECs to be Greek?  So if you had 5 ECs comprised of 3 Romans and 2 Greeks, this EE wouldn't discard a hero?  Because I can tell you, if I read the ability "If all your ECs are Romans or Greeks", I'm thinking to myself "I meet this condition as long as each of my ECs in play is either a Roman or a Greek". 

If this EE was intended to operate like Faith of Samuel, I'd word it like this:

"If all of your Evil Characters are Romans, or if all of your Evil Characters are Greek, discard a hero."

It's just that "or" statements, when used in logic, are mutually exclusive; if one of the two mutually exclusive conditions is true, then the whole statement is true.  Which leads me to believe that Faith of Samuel should be reworded as "If all of those heroes are Cloud heroes, or if all of those heroes share the same book, you may draw 3", if you want it to work as stated above. 

I guess for further clarification if someone were to only chose to band to 1 hero they would automatically meet the requirements to draw or does the card require heros indicating plural to be banded in for those conditions to apply? I feel I'm being overly analytical an nitpicky here but I figured I should ask anyways in case I was wrong.