Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Again, it wasn't just a two-person conversation that led to my impression of the tone of this thread.

though; no one has presented the very logical idea that it's an evil variation on the good Temples which hold the holy artifacts.

Quote from: YourMathTeacher on January 23, 2009, 08:07:04 PM

So says Schaef, Captain of the "Temple" Guard. 

oh that was bad.

Temple of A could be in someones STOREHOUSE, ok there ahem.

I would say Temple of Dagon is a Temple, it may be a false god, but its a REAL temple.

That seems presented to me.

I thought that all was implied by it being a real temple. Silly me.

Hey,

Based on the wording from Zerubbabel's Temple ("good Temple or Tabernacle") The Tabernacle would not qualify as a "good Temple" and thus would not qualify as a Temple for Desecrate the Temple.

Also since Zerubbabel's Temple specifies "good Temple" that suggests to me that there can be an evil (or possibly neutral) temple.  Since evil temple's can exist I can't imagine how Temple of Dagon would fail to qualify.

Herod's Temple is where it starts to become a little less clear to me, if only because it is not a Fortress.  But Desecrate the Temple doesn't say anything about the temple having to be a fortress.  Since there is no Fortress requirement I don't see how we can include Solomon's Temple and Temple of Dagon as temple's but not include Herod's Temple.

Temple of Nisroch seems pretty obvious to me as well, given the fact that Desecrate the Temple does not require the Temple to be a Fortress Temple of Nisroch seems to qualify just as much as Temple of Dagon does.

So I'm coming up with the following list of temples:

Solomon's Temple, Zerubbabel's Temple, Herod's Temple, Temple of Dagon, and Temple of Nisroch.

Tschow,

Tim "Sir Nobody" Maly

Honestly I think assyrian camp shoulda been the temple reprint because a building shouldn't be an enhancement.

Add more fuel to the fire.

We are supposed to be temples of the holy spirit yes?

I want to d/c my opp.

So I'm coming up with the following list of temples:

Solomon's Temple, Zerubbabel's Temple, Herod's Temple, Temple of Dagon, and Temple of Nisroch.

Personally, I would add House of Rimmon to the list.

Agreed. We can't be a game with 100 cards that don't really do what they say we do. We have to save that kind of thing for a card that might break the game(i.e. Holy Grail), which I don't think DtT is going to do.