Cactus Web Site special offer: Orders over $75 will receive a free Angel of God 2023 National Promo card while supplies last.
It's a new phase within another phase. Abilities don't end when a new phase starts, then end when the current phase ends.
Actually, abilities that aren't specifically ongoing continuously or until the end of the turn are only active in the phase they activated.
Quote from: Redoubter on May 16, 2012, 01:43:58 PMActually, abilities that aren't specifically ongoing continuously or until the end of the turn are only active in the phase they activated.That's correct. And the initial battle phase that AtC was played in is still going, so abilities active for that phase remain active.
Quote from: Redoubter on May 16, 2012, 01:20:58 AMQuote from: browarod on May 16, 2012, 12:48:28 AMIf Moses was in the original battle then I believe his FBTN would carry into AtC's new battle phase since that battle phase is nested inside the original phase which means Moses' effect hasn't ended yet. That is the difference between him originating in the first battle versus the second battle.Based on it being a new battle phase (arguing that side just because I can see both sides), it shouldn't. If it is a different phase as SirNobody suggests, then FBTN would not transfer, just like he suggests FBTN from the second battle would not transfer. Different phase, so no shared abilities.It's a new phase within another phase. Abilities don't end when a new phase starts, then end when the current phase ends. There is nothing about starting a new phase while one is ongoing that would stop Moses' ability which is why it carries over into the second battle phase. However, the second phase does actually end before the first resumes so that's why Moses' ability when used in the second battle ends after the second battle phase completes and doesn't carry back to the original, first phase.
Quote from: browarod on May 16, 2012, 12:48:28 AMIf Moses was in the original battle then I believe his FBTN would carry into AtC's new battle phase since that battle phase is nested inside the original phase which means Moses' effect hasn't ended yet. That is the difference between him originating in the first battle versus the second battle.Based on it being a new battle phase (arguing that side just because I can see both sides), it shouldn't. If it is a different phase as SirNobody suggests, then FBTN would not transfer, just like he suggests FBTN from the second battle would not transfer. Different phase, so no shared abilities.
If Moses was in the original battle then I believe his FBTN would carry into AtC's new battle phase since that battle phase is nested inside the original phase which means Moses' effect hasn't ended yet. That is the difference between him originating in the first battle versus the second battle.
I agree, thats why I suggest suggest having all of them in the same battle phase no matter what.
