The Play As, as quoted in the first post, includes: "When opponent presents an Evil Character in battle or chooses not to block, Hero is flipped face up." I think that makes it fairly clear, don't you?
Yes, I do. And that's a big -1 for me
For Prof... I think you said something about a female. But you can only set aside males. 
That is true. And that's a big -1 for me as well
Final score:
Prof "failing to read well before responding" Underwood -2
Everyone else >9000
