Cactus Game Design Message Boards

So Zach (The ArchAngel) and I had another stumper as usual, we ruled it as best we could and moved on, but would love some input!


Zach attacks with Seraph banded to Isaiah.
Joey blocks with Scribe, I play Balaam's Disobedience, False Peace.
Joey then plays Tenants Kill the Son to discard Seraph.

Scribe is now immune to human Isaiah, CBN.

Zach then plays Two Bears. He targets Tenants Kill the Son as a Black Brigade card, interrupting its Special Ability.

Taking the "simultaneous, yet consecutive" approach, we consider Seraph to have returned to battle. If that is true, and if Balaam's Disobedience is constantly checking it's triggers, then Scribe is no longer protected.

Zach then targets Scribe as a Gray Brigade card, shuffling him into my draw pile.


Did we rule this correctly? Please share your logic whether you agree or disagree so we can learn together

Two Bears interrupts the battle which interrupts Tenants Kill the Son (as the last enhancement played by the opponent). At that time, Seraph is still in battle since Tenants was interrupted. Balaam's Disobedience is an ongoing check so at all times (even during the resolution of other special abilities) it's updating based on its condition (an angel in battle). You can therefore select Scribe as a gray card to shuffle with Two Bears and Tenants as a black card.

So, tl;dr, you guys ruled correctly.

I agree.