Author Topic: ORCID Questions/Corrections  (Read 3022 times)

Offline Kevinthedude

  • Tournament Host
  • Trade Count: (+1)
  • *****
  • Posts: 1856
  • Yo
    • -
    • North Central Region
ORCID Questions/Corrections
« on: September 11, 2017, 11:19:57 AM »
+1
I was looking through ORCID and saw that the Resurrection soul from I has a play as of "resurrect a Hero" when the original wording was "search discard pile for a Hero". This changes the function of the card since the original wording would have allowed you to put the searched for Hero in hand while resurrect forces you to put it in play. The play as needs to be corrected or changed to errata.

Edit: Question about David's Harp. The original wording looks like the Hero never hits discard. The play as definitely involves the Hero hitting discard. This means David's Harp has a search ability now, correct?

Edit2: Spear of Joshua should specify human to be consistent with the other cards changed from "fought earthly battle".

Edit3: This is is more of a question since it seems intentional but maybe it is a correction. Why does Might of Angels has the play as "Discard all ECs with a N.T. reference on card" instead of just "Discard all N.T. ECs"?

Edit4: All cards that Banish an opponent's discard pile (or most of it) currently say "banish -cards- from a discard pile" when they should say "banish -cards- in a discard pile". I know this is pretty semantical but it should be consistent with similar abilities and the current wording really only makes sense if you're thinking of the English word banish instead of the ability banish. Cards don't say "banish a Hero from battle" for example.

Edit5: Shouldn't Leprosy utilize a colon?
Currently: "Place on a Hero to disease that Hero with leprosy. While Leprosy is in play, if it discards a Hero, place it on a Hero in the same territory to disease that Hero with leprosy. Each upkeep, decrease the Hero with leprosy 0/2."
Suggested: "Place on a Hero: Disease Hero. If leprosy discards Hero, repeat its ability. Each upkeep, decrease Hero 0/2."
If "repeat its ability" isn't something a card can do, just have it say "Place on a Hero: Disease Hero. Each upkeep, decrease Hero 0/2. If leprosy discards Hero, place on Hero: Disease Hero. Each upkeep, decrease Hero 0/2."

Edit6: To protect against the possibly future where Daves Harp can be made CBI, the "Negate David's Harp" part of 30 Pieces of Silver should be put before the other ability. This suggestion is kinda iffy but I think it actually does something.

Edit7: Per a recent ruling question, Redemption should only be able to target cards that are only a Hero at face value to prevent unintended interactions with DACs.

Edit8: If the leprosy suggestion is good, Sowing the Seed should be changed the same way.

Edit9: I'm unsure of an easy fix but New Togues either lets the Hero rescue the Female Only through soul protection like Fire Foxes or would not let it rescue the Female Only if the Female Only is the only soul opponent has, depending on the interpretation of "if a Lost Soul would be rescued by a Hero".

Edit10: To avoid ambiguity, Herod the Great should probably say "Withdraw all Heroes that were targeted by band abilities this turn".

Edit11: Flogging should specify if odd strength and toughness values are rounded up or down when halved. SubEdit: Also Betrayal.

Edit12: Either I misunderstand Lacking Sleep or it's functionality has been majorly changed by the play as. Should it not be "If Hero is blocked, the blocking player may play an enhancement. Limit once per battle. (Limit so you don't potentially get to play more than the first enhancement)" instead of "If that Hero is in battle, the blocking player may play an Enhancement". SubEdit: Also Without Food.

Edit13: Desertion should be "restrict players from playing good cards with banding abilities this turn". As is the play as stops evil banding cards as well as good ones while the original card only stops good banding.
« Last Edit: September 11, 2017, 02:26:02 PM by Kevinthedude »

 


SimplePortal 2.3.3 © 2008-2010, SimplePortal