Thanks for the recommendations! Here is my list after cataloguing my cards I got last week from everyone. Obviously if it doesn't have number, I don't have it...
1 Aaron's Staff
Altar of Ahaz
Altar of Burnt Offering
2 Altar of Dagon
Altar of Incense
Altar of Incense
Ark of the Covenant
Ark of the Covenant
1 Asherah Pole
3 Assyria's Tribute
Blue Tassels
Boaz' Sandal
Book of the Covenant
Book of the Law
1 Burial Shroud
Chariot of Fire
Chariot of Fire
6 Cross Beams of the Cross
Crown of Thorns
Darius' Decree
David's Harp
5 David's Harp
Denarius
Elijah's Mantle
1 Every Man's Sword
Four-Drachma Coin
Gifts of the Magi
Golden Calf
Golden Cherubim
1 Hezekiah's Signet Ring
1 Hidden Treasures
Holy Grail
Holy Grail
Holy of Holies
Holy of Holies
2 Household Idols
3 Iron Pan
6 Jacob's Ladder
7 Joseph's Silver Cup
King's Sword
King's Sword
Lampstand of the Sanctuary
1 Letters to the Corinthians
4 Letter to the Hebrews
Letters to the Philippians
Letters to the Thessalonians
Magic Charms
7 Miraculous Handkerchiefs
1 Miraculous Handkerchiefs
Moses' Rod
Paul’s Books and Parchments
2 Pitch and Gopher Wood
Pot of Manna
Priestly Breastplate
1 Priestly Breastplate
Priestly Crown
Ram's Horn
Ram's Horn
Samaritan Water Jar
2 Shrine to Artemis
2 Stalks of Flax
1 Stone Pillar at Bethel
Table of Showbread
1 Tables of the Law
Tables of the Law
Tables of the Law
Temple Veil
The Bronze Laver
1 The Master's Table
The Silver Trumpets
4 Thirty Pieces of Silver
3 Three Nails
3 Unholy Writ
Urim and Thummim
1 Wash Basin
Windows of Narrow Light
7 Wool Fleece
1 Wool Fleece