Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Is the double pack thing still shrink-wrapped? If so (which guarantees mint, unplayed condition), then that is probably worth around $20...it's more of a collector's item at this point. The booster packs (despite being from 1995) are still readily available and only worth $1 each retail.

Actually I would recommend trading them.  You could get more than $24 worth of cards for them, and the cards you would get would be a lot better for actually playing with than the original cards.  As someone first getting into the game, you don't really want a collectors item, you want something that is actually fun to play with.

I bet someone would be willing to trade an E/F or a G/H starter set, both of which are much more fun to play with, and are worth less, so they could probably throw in some other really useful cards to even the deal.

The market section here would probably be the best place to trade or sell it. There are a bunch of collectors and players that frequent this section.