Welcome to the Official Redemption® Message Board!
Total Members Voted: 40
Voting closed: March 14, 2012, 10:01:44 PM
postcount.add(1);
Agreed, Daniel is clearly the better hero here, I'll post another impact calculus in a minute to show that.
Quote from: Wings of Music on March 12, 2012, 11:08:29 AMAgreed, Daniel is clearly the better hero here, I'll post another impact calculus in a minute to show that.Not really, seeing as Salome can search for TGT, use TGT, and search for The New Cov.
Agreed, Daniel is clearly the better hero here, I'll post another impact calculus in a minute to show that.However what about Daniel? Dan counters everything in the meta defense even Gomer in some cases with his negates (+4 impact) He can band or look at hand, both useful abilities (+3 impact) as for enhancement stuff he's white/green giving him access to lots of awesome stuff and the ability to use HT for preblock wins (+3 impact). Lastly his CBN rounds him off well. (+2 impact) Total impact for Dan 12Search deck for TGT or N.T. cov, now that's pretty useful for a TGT deck. (+3 impact). Ignore ECs w/weapons, this is nice for getting around horsies, a helpful ability. (+2 impact). Salome is a TGT character (+4 impact), She actually has a good identifier (+ 1 impact). Total for Salome 10.Dan finishes with a two point advantage over Salome.
Quote from: Wings of Music on March 12, 2012, 11:08:29 AMAgreed, Daniel is clearly the better hero here, I'll post another impact calculus in a minute to show that.However what about Daniel? Dan counters everything in the meta defense even Gomer in some cases with his negates (+4 impact) He can band or look at hand, both useful abilities (+3 impact) as for enhancement stuff he's white/green giving him access to lots of awesome stuff and the ability to use HT for preblock wins (+3 impact). Lastly his CBN rounds him off well. (+2 impact) Total impact for Dan 12Search deck for TGT or N.T. cov, now that's pretty useful for a TGT deck. (+3 impact). Ignore ECs w/weapons, this is nice for getting around horsies, a helpful ability. (+2 impact). Salome is a TGT character (+4 impact), She actually has a good identifier (+ 1 impact). Total for Salome 10.Dan finishes with a two point advantage over Salome.Being serious now, here is what it should look like if we're scaling from 1 to 4:DanielAnti-meta: +4Band or Look at hand: + 1Green/White: +0Negate fortresses: + 1Negate NT enhancements: + 1Prophet: + 2CBN: + 1.5TOTAL: 10.5SalomeTGT user: +4TGT tutor: +4NT Female: +2NT covenant tutor: + 1Ignore EC's holding weapons: + 1TOTAL: 12I think this is a much more fair evaluation.
I'd argue that having two brigades is worth another 1.5 points.
What do you mean by a TGT tutor???
Quote from: Wings of Music on March 12, 2012, 11:08:29 AMAgreed, Daniel is clearly the better hero here, I'll post another impact calculus in a minute to show that.However what about Daniel? Dan counters everything in the meta defense even Gomer in some cases with his negates (+4 impact) He can band or look at hand, both useful abilities (+3 impact) as for enhancement stuff he's white/green giving him access to lots of awesome stuff and the ability to use HT for preblock wins (+3 impact). Lastly his CBN rounds him off well. (+2 impact) Total impact for Dan 12Search deck for TGT or N.T. cov, now that's pretty useful for a TGT deck. (+3 impact). Ignore ECs w/weapons, this is nice for getting around horsies, a helpful ability. (+2 impact). Salome is a TGT character (+4 impact), She actually has a good identifier (+ 1 impact). Total for Salome 10.Dan finishes with a two point advantage over Salome.Being serious now, here is what it should look like if we're scaling from 1 to 4:DanielAnti-meta: +4Band or Look at hand:+ 1 + 1.5 (look at hand is an amazing ability, and he has some cool peeps to band to) Green/White: +0 + 1 (C'mon 0 seriously? I know he doesn't have awesome white stuff but I still think the white/green should be factored in.)Negate fortresses: + 1Negate NT enhancements: + 1Prophet: + 2CBN: + 1.5TOTAL: 12SalomeTGT user: +4TGT tutor: +4 +3 (don't think the TGT tutor is that impactful, when' I've played TGT Salome rarely gets TGT out quickly enough to be worth it.) NT Female: +2NT covenant tutor: + 1Ignore EC's holding weapons: + 1TOTAL: 12 11I think this This is a much more fair evaluation.
Quote from: Master KChief on March 12, 2012, 12:27:24 PMQuote from: Wings of Music on March 12, 2012, 11:08:29 AMAgreed, Daniel is clearly the better hero here, I'll post another impact calculus in a minute to show that.However what about Daniel? Dan counters everything in the meta defense even Gomer in some cases with his negates (+4 impact) He can band or look at hand, both useful abilities (+3 impact) as for enhancement stuff he's white/green giving him access to lots of awesome stuff and the ability to use HT for preblock wins (+3 impact). Lastly his CBN rounds him off well. (+2 impact) Total impact for Dan 12Search deck for TGT or N.T. cov, now that's pretty useful for a TGT deck. (+3 impact). Ignore ECs w/weapons, this is nice for getting around horsies, a helpful ability. (+2 impact). Salome is a TGT character (+4 impact), She actually has a good identifier (+ 1 impact). Total for Salome 10.Dan finishes with a two point advantage over Salome.Being serious now, here is what it should look like if we're scaling from 1 to 4:DanielAnti-meta: +4Band or Look at hand: + 1 +2 (look at hand is an amazing ability, and he has some cool peeps to band to) Green/White: +0 + 1.5 (C'mon 0 seriously? I know he doesn't have awesome white stuff but I still think the white/green should be factored in.)Negate fortresses: + 1Negate NT enhancements: + 1Prophet: + 2CBN: + 1.5TOTAL: 13SalomeTGT user: +4TGT tutor: +4 +3 (don't think the TGT tutor is that impactful, when' I've played TGT Salome rarely gets TGT out quickly enough to be worth it.) NT Female: +2NT covenant tutor: + 1Ignore EC's holding weapons: + 1TOTAL: 12 11I think this This is a much more fair evaluation.
Quote from: Wings of Music on March 12, 2012, 11:08:29 AMAgreed, Daniel is clearly the better hero here, I'll post another impact calculus in a minute to show that.However what about Daniel? Dan counters everything in the meta defense even Gomer in some cases with his negates (+4 impact) He can band or look at hand, both useful abilities (+3 impact) as for enhancement stuff he's white/green giving him access to lots of awesome stuff and the ability to use HT for preblock wins (+3 impact). Lastly his CBN rounds him off well. (+2 impact) Total impact for Dan 12Search deck for TGT or N.T. cov, now that's pretty useful for a TGT deck. (+3 impact). Ignore ECs w/weapons, this is nice for getting around horsies, a helpful ability. (+2 impact). Salome is a TGT character (+4 impact), She actually has a good identifier (+ 1 impact). Total for Salome 10.Dan finishes with a two point advantage over Salome.Being serious now, here is what it should look like if we're scaling from 1 to 4:DanielAnti-meta: +4Band or Look at hand: + 1 +2 (look at hand is an amazing ability, and he has some cool peeps to band to) Green/White: +0 + 1.5 (C'mon 0 seriously? I know he doesn't have awesome white stuff but I still think the white/green should be factored in.)Negate fortresses: + 1Negate NT enhancements: + 1Prophet: + 2CBN: + 1.5TOTAL: 13SalomeTGT user: +4TGT tutor: +4 +3 (don't think the TGT tutor is that impactful, when' I've played TGT Salome rarely gets TGT out quickly enough to be worth it.) NT Female: +2NT covenant tutor: + 1Ignore EC's holding weapons: + 1TOTAL: 12 11I think this This is a much more fair evaluation.
Poll