Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Hey everyone! I'm working on getting this off the ground. Sorry for the delay, finals hit me hard, and I needed a breather afterwards. This thread is to decide the brackets for the individual brigades. The following are the evil characters (randomized within their brigades) as they'll play in the tournament. To use Multicolor as an example, Manny will face off against Antiochus in the first round. The winner of that will face off against the fight between Amalekite's Slave and Egyptian Magicians, and so on.

What I need from you all is a ranking of all eight evil brigades in order, from best to worst. I'll tally the results, and we'll bracket them like in a standard tournament (best will face worst to start, second best will face second worst, and so on). Once I have all that, which should hopefully take no more than a couple days, I'll develop a bracket, and give people a chance to make their own, to compete for some kind of cheap prize for whoever's bracket does the best.

If there are any questions or concerns, feel free to post in this thread or PM me. I'm hoping to start the first round no later than Friday, June 20th, though that might get pushed around depending on attendance.

MULTICOLOR
King Manasseh
Antiochus
Amalekite's Slave
Egyptian Magicians
Damsel with a Spirit of Divination
Foreign Spearmen
Scribe
Foreign Wives

ORANGE
Trembling Demon
King of Tyrus
Wandering Spirit
Seven Wicked Spirits
Foul Spirit
Deceiving Spirit
Spirit of Temptation
Prince of the Air

BLACK
Simon the Magician
Saph
12FG
Armorbearer
Goliath
Lots Wife
Gibeonite Delegates
The Woman of Thebez

BROWN
King Nadab
Gomer
King Rehoboam
Zimri, son of Salu
King Amon
Jeering youth
King Ahab
Uzzah

CRIMSON
Nergalsharezar
Seven Sons of Sceva
Nebushashban
Sapphira
Judas Iscariot
King Merodach-Baladan
Creeping Deceiver
Nebuchadnezzar

GOLD
Herod the Great
Herod Agrippa I
Warden
The Dreaming Pharaoh
Archeleus
Egyptian Charioteers
King of Tyrus
Pharoah's Cupbearer

GRAY
The Entrapping Pharasee
Emperor Vitteleus
Namaan
Emperor Tiberius
Sabbath Breaker
Emperor Galba
King Cush
Proud Pharissee

PALE GREEN
Assyrian Archer
Users of Curious Arts
Messenger of Satan
Assyrian Survivor
Balaam
Assyrian Siege Army
Woman as Snares
The Rabsaris

So you're looking for something like this:

1. Multicolor
2. Pale Green
3. Gray
4. Gold
5. Black
6. Orange
7. Crimson
8. Brown (?)

If so, that's mine.

This would have Multicolor and Brown going against each other in the first brigade vs. brigade round. Is that what you're looking for?

Edit: To clarify, I'm looking for 1. to be the best brigade in your opinion, and 8. to be the worst.

So you're looking for something like this:

1. Multicolor
8. Brown
4. Gold
5. Black
3. Gray
2. Pale Green
6. Orange
7. Crimson


If so, that's mine.

Yep. Didn't change the numbers because Brown so good.

1. Multicolor
2. Gray
3. Pale Green
4. Crimson
5. Brown
6. Gold
7. Orange
8. Black

100% based on t1