No theological problems there!
I feel like there could be a Santa Claus too. Something along the lines of Saint Patrick Promo.
Saint Nicholas, Joy-Giver
Identifier: Exclusively legal in type 1 multi. Also exclusively legal in type 2 multi. Barely legal in two player categories. Not legal for booster.
Red
Territory Class
When Saint Nicholas comes into play choose naughty or nice for all players. Naughty players are given a Canaanite from all players deck, territory, discard pile, banish zone, and/or reserve. Nice players search their deck for all fruits of the spirit and children. Cannot be negated by naughty players.