Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Wow. I don't even come close to any of those three criteria.

Congratulations Justin and Gabe on your selection. 

now this as some crtia 1:must have place top 16 or higher at nats 2:must NOT have cheated during a nats game 3:must be a good sport.

#1 - using that criteria would create a MUCH longer list
#2 - if Redemption has a Hall of Fame, it should only be the Best of the Best, and that criteria is too easy.
#3 - I like the idea of a Hall of Fame, I think I might set something up for this.

I've caught players intentionally cheating at my tournaments before, but nobody seemed to incensed at having their controllers unplugged right when they were about to smash their opponent into oblivion

I say we do the voting like the baseball hall of fame does its voting.  You have 10 or so people nominated (for any reason) in a year,( i.e the top 10 most nominated people get on the ballot) and then we have a vote on those 10 nominations and the nominations that recieve a high percentae of the vote (say greater than 50%) get nominated.  Each person votes for three people on a 10 person ballot and PM's those votes to two people (a ballot is only valid if it contains the same two people in the address line to prevent different ballots being sent to the two different counters.  They compile the results and check with each other before announcing the new members for the hall of fame that year.