Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Alright everyone, we are trying to determine the format to use for Boosters are North East Regionals.  I know a lot of people have preferences and opinions about the 'best' type of Booster Draft.  A lot of people dislike doing X and love doing Y, while still others swear by using Z.  So, I want to get your input before we make a decision

Please only respond if you will be attending the tournament and plan to play Booster (it will be played opposite Teams).  When you respond, select the number that you would prefer as the base, and then the letters that indicate the add-ons you would like to have included.  The price per player for the option is listed at the start of each of the letters.  All options besides the first will show the amount added to that base cost, so that you know how much your vote would cost you  

We will tally the votes and take them all into consideration before posting the final format.  Thank you!

1. One of each in-print foil pack (Unlimited, Prophets, Apostles, Patriarchs, Kings, Angel Wars, Priests).
     a. ($15) No additional packs.
     b. (+$3) Add Womens.
     c. (+$4) Add Disciples.
     d. (+$4) Add TexP.

2. One FooF or RoA tin (all tins 1-25) and one of each foil pack included in tins (Unlimited, Prophets, Apostles, Patriarchs, Kings, Priests).
     a. ($15) No additional packs.
     b. (+$3) Add Womens.
     c. (+$2) Add Angel Wars.
     d. (+$4) Add Disciples.
     e. (+$4) Add TexP.

3. One FooF or RoA tin from only the 2011 release (tins 20-25) and one of each foil pack included in tins (Unlimited, Prophets, Apostles, Patriarchs, Kings, Priests).
     a. ($15) No additional packs.
     b. (+$3) Add Womens.
     c. (+$2) Add Angel Wars.
     d. (+$4) Add Disciples.
     e. (+$4) Add TexP.

Examples:
If I were a purist that disliked tins, but wanted all the foils and packs, I would reply with this format:

I vote for 1bcd

Or if I liked just the new tins and only the packs that come in them, I would reply with this format:

I vote for 3a

1b.  Tins make booster entirely unfun.

EDIT: changing to 1bc.  Tins are still unfun.

1b.  Agree with Drrek, tins are kind of annoying to deal with.  Picking option b due to thinking about overall cost for players.  And women's makes booster really good.

1b

I can't say until I know the flights, but I'd be 1bcd

1bcd

I know this is late, but voting is CLOSED.  Here are the results with the 10 votes received:

Base Type

Foil-Only	New Tins	All Tins
6	3	1

Winning Type: One of each In-Print Foil Pack (Unlimited, Prophets, Apostles, Patriarchs, Kings, Angel Wars, Priests)

Additions (Overall)

None	Womens	Disciples	TexP
0	8	3	6

Additions (Winning Type Only, 6 Votes)

None	Womens	Disciples	TexP
0	6	2	3

Additions Selected: One Womens and One TexP

Booster Draft will cost $22 to play, and will consist of one of each of the following: Unlimited, Prophets, Apostles, Patriarchs, Kings, Angel Wars, Priests, Womens, TexP

Thank you for voting!