Welcome to the Official Redemption® Message Board!
I had someone rip a Haman's Plot against me in a tournament last week, then realize he couldn't legally play it (I missed that, too). He held it for the rest of the game without ever getting a chance to play it, so it was ripped for nothing-and it belonged to someone else!! (However, Justin never seems to mind the loss of another HP. I've seen him pull one out of a booster pack and rip it immediately!)My son Robert had a Haman's Plot ripped against him by Rob Anderson. It was his first attempt at the "it doesn't count; since the sizes are unequal it's not ripped in HALF" defense. (Rob overruled him.)
Once you start you can't stop.
I think I ripped about 25 last season, though I think they were all at least in State-level tournaments.
"You're gonna pay for that!"