Cactus Game Design Message Boards

I feel that for the most part that Redemption is still mostly biblical. There are some cards that are controversial like Falling Away and the Emperors but can still be justified biblically. The only unbiblical card would be Saint Patrick but that's just one card in there more just for fun. Also wether it's biblical or not it does teach people a lot about the Bible and has been helping me in my Old Testament Literature class.
'

I am trying to start a playgroup at my church for the first time.  While explaining the game to the pastor he brought up some good points regarding aspects of the game and if they were Biblical or not.  I would like to ask the Redemption community what your opinion is on how Biblical Redemption is and how much Biblical authenticy has been lost in the process of progressing the game and making Biblical stories and ideas fit in to a card game.  Also, any advice on starting a play group and working with parents and a church in regards to Redemption would be greatly appreciated.  Thanks and Godbless

Sorry, but this is just too vague.  Can you ask SPECIFIC questions about what aspects of the game are biblical?  Obviously the word "Redemption" is a bible word.  There is a bible verse on almost every card.  God and Jesus are glorified and all-powerful.  Bad guys in the bible are generally bad guys in the game, and the same for heroes.  So it's already "biblical" in these senses.  What exactly are you wonderingif it is "biblical" or not?

The game is based on biblical characters, events, places, etc. from the Bible. There is also some loose theology involved. I would say that, while the game is based on the Bible, it is not, inherently, biblical. Obviously, the apostle Paul never removed The Serpent from the game. I believe that making the distinction between "is the hero rescuing them or merely leading them to Christ" is just splitting hairs in regards to a children's card game.

By rescuing it is signifying that the soul is redeemed or found God (which happened in the Old Testament). Land of Redemption should not be the same as Land of Bondage. All the battles represent a what if scenario instead of actual encounters

My pastor's questions were referring mostly about lost souls what what it means to rescue them (is it the hero recusing them or just the hero leading them to Christ?

More importantly, we as Christians are competing with each other to rescue the most souls. I am obviously a better Christian than you if I have a higher Lost Soul count. Give me my crown in heaven, and 50 booster packs please.

ITT: People trying to make a card game way to serious, no matter what it's based on it's a game no it's not going to follow the Bible exactly (see Christian martyring every OT hero, Goliath repeatedly beating David (i did it twice in a game just a few games ago) using Son of God to rescue lost souls from the Old Testament, and generally any battle ever in redemption, it's very rare that you actually have two people from the same time frame or that ever even MET eat other. For that matter we are all trying to STOP other people from rescuing souls when [if in the case of olijar] we use defense)

"Is Redemption Really Biblical?"

Yes.  Inasmuch as it is a game.  It has limited mechanics that simulate Biblical scenarios to a point, but I would suggest you liken it to Scripture only so far as you would want a game to take the place of your Bible for discerning doctrine and forming your life philosophies.

My pastor's questions were referring mostly about lost souls what what it means to rescue them (is it the hero recusing them or just the hero leading them to Christ?

Does your pastor feel that humans have a role in God's plan of Redemption or not?  As a pastor, I would imagine he feels there is a part for us to play.  Redemption has never espoused that humans are capable of directly sanctifying other humans from sin, I can tell you that much.

if it is leading them to Christ, then how do OT heros rescue souls?)

Again, the existence of the Old Testament among the Scriptures leads to the conclusion that their stories are part of the Grand Design as well.  Hebrews 11 doesn't seem to think their efforts were for naught.

Again, this is a game, one that simulates Biblical scenarios and principles in broad strokes.  There are going to be departures due to the dynamic nature of the game, something the industry calls "emergent gameplay".  If there is irreconcilable theological problems, they tend to get weeded out (e.g. the recent ruling stopping people from capturing a demon and then redeeming its soul).  That may or may not be enough for some boards - I've been turned down as many places as I've been accepted - but I think for a game, it's sufficient.

I don't think this game or any other game should be in any means a thesis to biblical interpretation/teaching... You should use the Bible for that. Its a fun game and some people use it as a way to get a foot in the door to explain their faith.... Teaching people from the game I think is somewhat not the best idea.

Well, that's very orthodox and uncompromising, but with some kids, you'll lose them. If that's ok with you, then fine.

Quote

I don't think this game or any other game should be in any means a thesis to biblical interpretation/teaching... You should use the Bible for that. Its a fun game and some people use it as a way to get a foot in the door to explain their faith.... Teaching people from the game I think is somewhat not the best idea.

Well, that's very orthodox and uncompromising, but with some kids, you'll lose them. If that's ok with you, then fine.

I'm not a very orthodox person. I'm just saying, I think its good for opening the door for expressing your faith, but the game isn't the best example of true biblical events/principles (if that's what you are trying to teach). If you are trying to teach virtues such as patience and good sportsmanship and fellowship and friendly competition and the concept of salvation, then I think the game is good for that.

If you want a game that exactly represents what the Bible says/theology, try real life.  If a pastor won't be happy until it's perfect, then go sow your seed elsewhere.