Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Should be worded:

"...you may remove this card and your evil Canaanite from the game..."

Technically this wording would let you choose a good Canaanite (or one that is captured), and also allow you to select your opponent's Canaanite (good, evil, or neutral).  Unless it is your own, being used as an evil character, this would not be balanced.

what if it said OT prophet or just elijah or elisha?

Too many prophets in the game for this to be worthwhile. Virtually every theme as at least one prophet (Genesis has Joseph, Sam has all sorts of guys, Disciples have John and Peter, etc), and I just don't think I'd use it unless that stipulation was repealed, or changed somehow.

Last I checked Peter is not a Prophet. John is because he wrote Revelation.
Besides that, I think the card is not to crazy.

peter is effective against the  if use a gardensciples due to TGT

This card kinda reminds me of a card called Baal Worship.

That is because it is basically a reprint with a different name and better ability.

The biggest problem is it's too easy to circumvent with pretty much every theme. I, personally, would not use it a Canaanite defense because I'd rather have a card that might get a block, but if it works, is also doing damage to my opponent beyond a stall. Then again, I guess the best cards are cards that some people would use and others wouldn't. Carry on then.

I understand your point, but I also feel that making cards 'everyone' would use is silly, despite the number of them out there already.

And note that you can still choose when to use this card.  If you haven't gotten rid of their prophet and he attacks, just block normally.  Otherwise, you have a (effectively CBN) chump block that is still balanced in its cost (since you cannot recur the Canaanite), so long as the wording is tweaked.

Updated

I would change it to "Place this in your territory: During battle you may remove this card and..." so that you can use it during battle as a block, although I don't see why this need the removal, I think discard would be good enough (discard this card and your evil Canaanite).

Or, how about:
"Place this card in your territory: During battle you may capture your Canaanite to protect OT Lost Souls from rescue except by an OT Prophet."

This is somewhat more powerful, but the idea is that you generate souls for your opponent on later turns while protecting yourself on this turn, however I'm not sure if this is the right card for this ability. Another idea is give a Canaanite to your opponent representing them "infecting" Israel.

having your EC discarded isn't as big a deal for canaanites, because of Fortify Site and to a lesser extent, Pharaoh's Cupbearer, especially in type II.

This.  All of the Canaanites can be brought back with Fortify Site, and 3 (at least) can be brought back with Cupbearer.  Removing them from the game is definitely necessary.

Or, how about:
"Place this card in your territory: During battle you may capture your Canaanite to protect OT Lost Souls from rescue except by an OT Prophet."

This is somewhat more powerful, but the idea is that you generate souls for your opponent on later turns while protecting yourself on this turn, however I'm not sure if this is the right card for this ability. Another idea is give a Canaanite to your opponent representing them "infecting" Israel.

Do not like the capturing to your own LoB because Shechem can just punt them over to the other side when he blocks anyway.

On giving your opponent Canaanites, yes that is something that the theme already does, but I don't think it is a balanced enough cost (because you can still get them back to easily and it sets up more CTB).

How about single brigade green prophet or something like that?
It would stop most meta offenses and give Canaanites a boost they need.

Is there a precedent for specifying that it can only be single-color?  Right now, the card has been updated to say "...except by a Green OT Prophet", and honestly I thought it was balanced before.  This restriction is already good enough, IMO and doesn't need to be adjusted.

Quote from: The M on April 28, 2012, 12:42:34 PM

How about single brigade green prophet or something like that?
It would stop most meta offenses and give Canaanites a boost they need.

Is there a precedent for specifying that it can only be single-color?  Right now, the card has been updated to say "...except by a Green OT Prophet", and honestly I thought it was balanced before.  This restriction is already good enough, IMO and doesn't need to be adjusted.

I would personally like cards that would target multi color heroes and evil characters.

Stops Samuel and Joesph

Samuel needs stopping, Joe is not a big prob in my opinion