Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Redemption® Collectible Trading Card Game HQ => Redemption® Resources and Thinktank => New Card Ideas => Topic started by: The Warrior on September 20, 2010, 05:12:41 PM

Title: Question
Post by: The Warrior on September 20, 2010, 05:12:41 PM
Why dont my Cards Get very many comments?

is it the cards or The fact that I'm Posting them?
Just wondering
 :)
Title: Re: Question
Post by: Smokey on September 20, 2010, 07:19:46 PM
Inb4 no one else posting.
Probably both.
Title: Re: Question
Post by: stefferweffer on September 20, 2010, 07:41:10 PM
I looked at your previous 8 posts in this forum as a reference.  Those previous 8 posts have 65 replies, meaning you're averaging over 8 comments per thread.  I think I'd love to get 8 comments per thread I came up with.  Is this not very many comments, in your opinion?
Title: Re: Question
Post by: The Warrior on September 20, 2010, 09:37:55 PM
I looked at your previous 8 posts in this forum as a reference.  Those previous 8 posts have 65 replies, meaning you're averaging over 8 comments per thread.  I think I'd love to get 8 comments per thread I came up with.  Is this not very many comments, in your opinion?
Not merely a number but the posts like posts that say "im a n00b i like dis card lolololz" doeskin mean very much
Title: Re: Question
Post by: TheKarazyvicePresidentRR on September 20, 2010, 10:06:59 PM
I looked at your previous 8 posts in this forum as a reference.  Those previous 8 posts have 65 replies, meaning you're averaging over 8 comments per thread.  I think I'd love to get 8 comments per thread I came up with.  Is this not very many comments, in your opinion?
Not merely a number but the posts like posts that say "im a n00b i like dis card lolololz" doeskin mean very much
some of it comes from the way you "Make" cards. They are very hard to read and not aesthetically pleasing. On the other hand they are usually completely broken or completely useless. On the bright side, you're consistently making "completely" cards.
Title: Re: Question
Post by: Minister Polarius on September 21, 2010, 01:16:55 AM
Using a more standard format for presentation will help. I'm not saying the one I use is the only way to do it, but technically since my posts make up the majority of all card ideas, it could be considered "the standard" by default. But if you use something similar (including the "real" standard format that the playtesters use) instead of the way yo do it, you may get more comments. For reference, here is the way I do it:

Card Name
(S/T) (Brigade) Card Type, (Class)
(-Identifiers-)
"Special Ability"
~Verse

The things in parentheses are only when applicable.
Title: Re: Question
Post by: joeycauldron on September 21, 2010, 09:42:42 AM
Why dont my Cards Get very many comments?

is it the cards or The fact that I'm Posting them?
Just wondering
 :)
Well it is probably that someone else has already pointed out the flaws (if there are any) and you have fixed them. People also post a little like I was going to say so it would be copying them if I posted again.  :)
Title: Re: Question
Post by: The Warrior on September 21, 2010, 06:29:35 PM
I looked at your previous 8 posts in this forum as a reference.  Those previous 8 posts have 65 replies, meaning you're averaging over 8 comments per thread.  I think I'd love to get 8 comments per thread I came up with.  Is this not very many comments, in your opinion?
Not merely a number but the posts like posts that say "im a n00b i like dis card lolololz" doeskin mean very much
some of it comes from the way you "Make" cards. They are very hard to read and not aesthetically pleasing. On the other hand they are usually completely broken or completely useless. On the bright side, you're consistently making "completely" cards.
huh and huh?  ???
Title: Re: Question
Post by: The M on September 21, 2010, 06:42:36 PM
I looked at your previous 8 posts in this forum as a reference.  Those previous 8 posts have 65 replies, meaning you're averaging over 8 comments per thread.  I think I'd love to get 8 comments per thread I came up with.  Is this not very many comments, in your opinion?
Not merely a number but the posts like posts that say "im a n00b i like dis card lolololz" doeskin mean very much
some of it comes from the way you "Make" cards. They are very hard to read and not aesthetically pleasing. On the other hand they are usually completely broken or completely useless. On the bright side, you're consistently making "completely" cards.
huh and huh?  ???
huh and huh is correct. I will try my best to transilate. Here Goes:  "People think your cards are OP'D or UP'D. You somethingsomethingsomethingsomething." I agree with this statement.
The only person who consistently makes good cards in my opinion is BubbleBoy.
I don't think very many people have many comments unless they get into some huge arguement.
Usually it is just:
card.
like.
dislike.
how about...
edited.
Title: Re: Question
Post by: The Warrior on September 21, 2010, 06:49:32 PM
I looked at your previous 8 posts in this forum as a reference.  Those previous 8 posts have 65 replies, meaning you're averaging over 8 comments per thread.  I think I'd love to get 8 comments per thread I came up with.  Is this not very many comments, in your opinion?
Not merely a number but the posts like posts that say "im a n00b i like dis card lolololz" doeskin mean very much
some of it comes from the way you "Make" cards. They are very hard to read and not aesthetically pleasing. On the other hand they are usually completely broken or completely useless. On the bright side, you're consistently making "completely" cards.
huh and huh?  ???
huh and huh is correct. I will try my best to transilate. Here Goes:  "People think your cards are OP'D or UP'D. You somethingsomethingsomethingsomething." I agree with this statement.
The only person who consistently makes good cards in my opinion is BubbleBoy.
I don't think very many people have many comments unless they get into some huge arguement.
Usually it is just:
card.
like.
dislike.
how about...
edited.

fixed Bolded i agree
Many Cards have got lots of comments other than flame wars

Title: Re: Question
Post by: The M on November 06, 2010, 12:39:00 PM
True 'nuff. It is usually because people get into arguments about things that just take up 2 posts and that is all it needs to get a thread going.
SimplePortal 2.3.3 © 2008-2010, SimplePortal