Cactus Game Design Message Boards

It's Falling Away

This is a pretty decent twist on a classic.

I would support this idea more if it protected ALL Lost Souls from discard.  More balanced.

Well I don't want my opponent to be able to play doms at all, but that doesn't make sense.

You are proposing enhancing an existing dominant to counter two dominants instead of just one, and in a time where now we have dom cap and each slot is more important.  If you're going to add on to Guardian like this, then you'd have to make it balanced, and you'd have a choice about whether to include Burial or use the old Guardian.

What is going to discard it?  Seriously, find all the cards that do that, all I can find are:

Desecrate the Temple (better target than SoG to me anyway...)
Abomination of Desolation

That is it.  Unlike Good, Evil does not have things that just target "good cards," they specify character or enhancement when they target things in play for an effect.  If you can find more, then maybe there is an argument to be had, but as it stands there is just no weakness to having Guardian in territory in 99% of games.