New Redemption Grab Bag now includes an assortment of 500 cards from five (5) different expansion sets. Available at Cactus website.
Perhaps set aside 3 heroes for 3 turns then. Keep in mind that this was a punishment from God to DAVID.
But his evil acts had consequences for other innocent people (heroes). I guess I don't see how else you could have a card that represents God chastizing otherwise good people, which happens quite a bit in the bible. You can't have it be an evil card of course. And it shouldn't be something that a hero volunteers for, like set aside enhancements. Sometimes God punishes good people for their sins. You can't get around this. So if we start a precedent for allowing this I think we are on strong scriptural ground. After all, if the person doesn't like option 2 then they should choose something else