Cactus Game Design Message Boards

Hi there,

topic says it all and to bring up this topic again (there has been a similar thread several years ago): If you have the (free) choice how do you decide upon which LS to include in your deck (mainly T1)? And does it differ between T1 and T2? Of course there might be some staples like Lawless or similar - but besides those: How do you make your choice and why?

Looking forward to get some insights! 

Bye

Thanks Gabe!

After the staples I choose them based on which ones help my deck strategy.

If you don't mind maybe you could give some examples (also from older decks)?

Personally I really like where the LS pool is right now--obviously there's some LS that are found in nearly every deck because they enhance nearly every strategy, so really the most strategic decisions become the "non-staple" selections.

One classic example that I like to give is the Forsaken LS, which I don't think hardly anyone considers a "staple." With so much CBN and CBP banding available, it might seem like it's not worth the slot. However, if your strategy on offense, defense or both is not very strong against banding, then giving yourself that extra potential to stop banding could be exactly what you need. It is also a LS that people often forget or don't pay attention to because they are using CBN or CBP banding so they don't use Woes or Son of God to deal with it. Countless times I have seen people misplay thinking that they will be able to band, and suddenly they are stuck with a suboptimal rescue or block.

However, I think the LS strategy will become very interesting if and when we make a "Negate O.T. Lost Souls" LS (so a player can use the N.T. souls and negate LS for opponents running O.T. LS). 

It might for a time, but then everyone realizes that half the time they aren't going to getting any value from their OT/NT negate LS, and they begin to wonder if that slot could be better used...and the cycle continues...

You could also see more of a split between OT and NT souls to mitigate disruption. It would also probably influence toward inclusion of some souls that are not impacted (Humble and CBP).  Humble is a staple today anyway.

I actually disagree with Humble being a staple (though obviously it's a matter of preference and opinion). If I'm using a deck that does a lot of drawing and searching then my hand is likely to be larger than my opponents more often than not. Furthermore, if I'm using Humble and my opponent is running Wanderer, then I'm potentially going to be facing two Humbles.

Quote from: goalieking87 on February 18, 2019, 07:20:30 PM

You could also see more of a split between OT and NT souls to mitigate disruption. It would also probably influence toward inclusion of some souls that are not impacted (Humble and CBP).  Humble is a staple today anyway.

I actually disagree with Humble being a staple (though obviously it's a matter of preference and opinion). If I'm using a deck that does a lot of drawing and searching then my hand is likely to be larger than my opponents more often than not. Furthermore, if I'm using Humble and my opponent is running Wanderer, then I'm potentially going to be facing two Humbles.

I definitely see what you are saying, and don’t disagree. I was heading out the door when I tried to write my first message so wasn’t too careful with words and might not have referenced it as a “staple” if I had taken more time.

However, it also depends somewhat on your definition of “staple.” Does it mean that it goes in 100% of decks, no questions asked? Or if it would go in 90% of decks, could it still be a staple? 80%?

If the definition of staple is that they would go in 100% of decks, then I’m not sure there are really many out there outside of doms.

I probably try to run Humble in more than 85% of my decks.

That said, I also don’t consider myself to be an amazing deck builder and most of the time the Lost Souls are one of the last things to be modified for me. So if I start a deck concept, it will likely have Humble in it to start (benefits with the ability as well as targeted as OT or NT Soul), and if I never finish refining the deck, it never comes out.